Online Ordering Now Open. Ordering Deadline Tuesday 3/9/21 by 5pm!

*Click Here to order: Me, Myself & Pies Online Pickup Menu, Pre-Order for Jacksonville or Fernandina Pickup.

Savory

Individual Savory pie/ 9" Whole Savory (Serves 8) **Seasonal and baked from scratch. **Pies available for pre-order in advance required via website or call business line, refer to calendar for schedule.

Chicken Pot Pies

6in"-$8/9in"-$25

Chunks of white meat with carrots, potatoes & onions in a creamy herb sauce.

Beef Pot Pie

6in"-$8/9in"-$25

Tender chunks of beef with carrots, potatoes & onions in a rich beef gravy.

Vegetable Pot Pie

6in"-$8/9in"-$25

Al dente' cooked broccoli, carrots, peas, potatoes, celery & onions in a creamy vegetable herb sauce.

Cottage/Shepherd's Pie

6in"-$9/9in"-$26

A Me, Myself & Pies exclusive! We've married the British and Irish aspect of Pie - Ground Beef & Lamb mixed

Quiche options

Prices vary based on size and content

Loaded-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Lorraine-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Seafood-6in"-$10/9in"-$30

Vegetable-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Bacon & Spinach-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Broccoli & Bacon- 6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Pork Sage Sausage-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Turkey Sage Sausage-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Chicken Cordon Bleu-6in"-$8/9in"-$22

Sweet

Cutie Pie Bites (2 ")/ Mini Pies ( 3")/ Individual 6" Pies/ Whole 9" Pies **Seasonal and baked from scratch. **Pies available for pre-order in advance required via website or call business line, refer to calendar for schedule.

Fruit Pies

Seasonal 2in"-$2.50| 3in"-$3.50| 6in"-$7.50| 9in"-$22-$26 prices varies

Apple Blueberry Cherry Mixed Berry Peach Pear Peach-Mango Strawberry Strawberry Supreme

Cream & Custard Pies

2in"-$2.50| 3in"-$3.50| 6in"-$7.50| 9in"-$22-$26 prices varies

Buttermilk Pecan Pumpkin Key Lime Coconut Cream Chocolate French Silk Chocolate Chess Lemon Meringue Lemon Supreme Derby Mango Key Lime Sweet Potato

Specialty Pies

2in"-$2.50| 3in"-$3.50| 6in"-$7.50| 9in"-$22-$26 prices varies

Oreo Southern Paradise Peanut Butter Reese's Snicker's Butterfinger Chocolate Peanut Butter Butterscotch

All of our products contain eggs, dairy, sugar and gluten unless otherwise noted. Our products are made in a facility that contains nuts.

About Us

Handcrafted Goods

Me, Myself & Pies is a pie catering company specializing in sweet and savory pies in a variety of size (2, 3, 6, & 9 in"). Everything is made from scratch, by hand, incorporating natural, seasonal and local ingredients to every extent possible.

Where to find us!

Me, Myself & Pies does not operate a storefront yet, so everything we bake is made to order for pick-up by appointment only at a commercial kitchen in Riverside every 2nd and 4th Friday (By appointment only with a $40 minimum order) and at the Fernandina Beach Farmers Market every 2nd and 4th Saturday (9a-1p) of each month.

Catering

Need catering! For large orders, catering requests, and special events, please email us with your request with “Catering Request” in the subject line to: orders@memyselfandpies.com Commercial kitchen pickup and delivery available in select Jacksonville areas for an additional charge.

Visit Us

Visit for Pie!

We often run out of our signature items and we recommend visiting us early and/or ordering online.

We also make some additional sweet and savory that are available for purchase on a first come, first serve basis.

If you’d like to ensure that you have your pie order waiting for you, we encourage you to place an order online by or before Tuesday 5pm for pickup every 2nd and 4th Saturday of the month at the Fernandina Beach Farmers Market!

Me, Myself & Pies

1020 Park St, Jacksonville, Florida 32204, United States- Commercial Kitchen location------------- North 7th Street, Fernandina Bech, Fl. 32034- Fernandina Beach Farmers Market Location

904.757.2227

Hours

Order Me, Myself & Pies online for Sweet & Savory pies: To pick-up products; find them on the 2nd & 4th Saturdays of the month at the Fernandina Beach Farmers Market 9am-1pm and at our rented Commercial Kitchen space ( Home of Motion Sweets Bakery - 1020 Park St. Jacksonville, Fl. 32204) by appointment only 2nd & 4th Fridays of the month with a $40 minimum order.

Photo Gallery

Menu

Savory

Chicken Pot Pies

Beef Pot Pie

Vegetable Pot Pie

Cottage/Shepherd's Pie

Quiche options

Sweet

Fruit Pies

Cream & Custard Pies

Specialty Pies

About Us

Handcrafted Goods

Where to find us!

Catering

Visit Us

Visit for Pie!

Me, Myself & Pies

Hours